|
Minutes
of the Annual General Meeting 2008 of the Community of
Owners
of Faro Park Phases 1 and 2
called
by the President, Mrs Anne Head
Time:
Wednesday, 1st
October 2008 at 17:00
– first call
Venue:
Hotel Natura
Palace in Playa Blanca, Yaíza, Lanzarote
At
17:20 the President, Mrs Anne Head, called the Annual General Meeting to
order in the first call, pursuant to notifications of 5th September 2008
with the following:
AGENDA
1.
Registration of participants, presentation of proxies.
2.
The President's Report.
3.
Examination and approval, if appropriate, of the annual accounts for the
year 2007/2008.
4.
To update and agree on the list of debtors and to adopt resolutions for
taking legal steps for the recovery of outstanding amounts, giving the
necessary instructions and authorisations to the President. An updated
list of debtors will be presented at the meeting.
5.
Proposals from the Board:
a.
To amend the second paragraph of section 24 of the bye laws to
read as follows; "The meeting elects a President, who represents
the community in legal matters and additionally in all the matters
which affect it. Additionally it elects a Secretary-Administrator, one
or more Vice-presidents and an Auditor. (Unanimous)
b.
To erect a fence and install gates around the swimming pool so as to
increase security, in particular for children. The cost of this
depends on the quality and height of the fence and will be
approximately €12.000. (Simple majority)
c.
To tidy up, add some plants and install a watering system in the
unfinished area between phases 1 and 2 to the same standard as around
the swimming pool. Various quotes have been received, from €4.500 to
€7.500 (Simple majority)
d.
To delete the current Internal Rules and to adopt the new set of
Rules presented by the Board. (Simple majority)
e.
To install individual letterboxes as on the other phases of Faro
Park. Cost per property approximately €85.
6.
Proposals from owners:
a.
From Mr. Sam Magee (58):
i.
That any Board members or officers of the community who have
access to personal details of their fellow owners use this
information with discretion while they are in office. On retiring
from office, use of this classified information is in violation of
the Data Protection Act. (Simple majority)
ii.
That out of pocket expenses incurred by Board members be capped at
an agreed figure for each yearly term of appointment. (Simple
majority)
b.
From Mr. Tony Matthews (85): That I be reimbursed €581.04 in
telephone expenses for the three years that I was President. (Simple
majority)
7.
Proposal for the yearly budget and stipulation of annual fees.
8.
Elections:
a.
President
b.
Vice-President
c.
Vice-President Treasurer
d.
Secretary – Administrator
e.
Auditor
9.
Any other business
1.
Registration of participants, presentation of proxies
|
Owner |
Villa
No. |
Share
of Participation |
|
Green,
proxy to T. Head |
3 |
0.98% |
|
Meineck,
proxy to S. Magee |
4 |
0.98% |
|
Roelling |
6 |
0.98% |
|
Millard
R, proxy to P. Bookless |
9 |
0.98% |
|
Armstrong |
10 |
0.98% |
|
Burstein,
proxy to K. Bookless |
12 |
0.98% |
|
Millard
K, proxy to P. Bookless |
13 |
0.98% |
|
Bautista
Glez, proxy to A. Head |
14/21 |
1.96% |
|
Bookless |
15 |
0.98% |
|
Morgan |
16 |
0.98% |
|
Poole |
17 |
0.98% |
|
Hargreaves |
18 |
0.98% |
|
Ruiz,
proxy to A. Head, but no voting right |
20 |
0.98
% |
|
Highfield,
proxy to B. Hargreaves |
24 |
0.98% |
|
Ojeda
Douillet, proxy to A. Head |
26 |
0.98% |
|
Morillo,
proxy to A. Head |
28 |
0.98% |
|
Betancort
S.L, proxy to A. Head |
33/34/38/39 |
3.92% |
|
Haigh,
proxy to T. Head |
41 |
0.98% |
|
Blanchfield,
proxy to B. Hargreaves |
44 |
0.98% |
|
Scott,
proxy to A. Head |
45 |
0.98% |
|
Wingrove,
proxy to T. Head |
46 |
0.98% |
|
Page,
proxy to T. Head |
48 |
0.98% |
|
Mawson,
proxy to A. Head |
49 |
0.98% |
|
Theissen |
51 |
0.98% |
|
James |
52 |
0.98% |
|
Caterall,
proxy to J. James |
53 |
0.98% |
|
Magee |
58 |
0.98% |
|
Johnson,
proxy to R. Stansfield |
59 |
0.98% |
|
Martin,
proxy to S. Jones |
61 |
0.98% |
|
Edwards,
proxy to A. Head |
62 |
0.98% |
|
Ludvigsen,
proxy to T. Head |
63 |
0.98% |
|
Whelan,
proxy to T. Head |
64 |
0.98% |
|
Head |
65 |
0.98% |
|
Blayney,
proxy to S. Magee |
66 |
0.98% |
|
Manuel
Gallego, proxy to A. Head |
68 |
0.98% |
|
Paluch,
proxy to S. Magee |
69 |
0.98% |
|
Harvey
W, proxy to T. Head |
70 |
0.98% |
|
Roach |
71 |
0.98% |
|
Harvey
G, proxy to M. Roach |
72 |
0.98% |
|
Herz |
73 |
0.98% |
|
Delduca,
proxy to A. Head |
74 |
0.98% |
|
Koch |
75 |
0.98% |
|
Stansfield |
76 |
0.98% |
|
Crabtree |
77 |
0.98% |
|
Billington,
proxy to S. Magee |
78 |
0.98% |
|
Skipper,
proxy to A. Head but no voting right |
79 |
0.98
% |
|
Pieper |
80 |
0.98% |
|
Wright,
proxy to R. Stansfield |
81 |
0.98% |
|
Hernandez |
83 |
0.98% |
|
Matthews,
proxy to S. Jones |
85 |
0.98% |
|
McDonnell,
proxy to S. Magee |
86 |
0.98% |
|
Lee,
proxy to Mrs Jones |
88 |
0.98% |
|
Jones
C. |
89 |
0.98% |
|
Teifel |
91 |
0.98% |
|
Shaw
& Smart, proxy to V. Morgan |
92 |
0.98% |
|
Sherwood,
proxy to A. Head |
93 |
0.98% |
|
Morris |
94 |
0.98% |
|
McLauchlin,
proxy to S. Jones |
95 |
0.98% |
|
Mankner,
proxy to Mrs Teifel |
96 |
0.98% |
|
Santamaria,
proxy to S. Magee |
97 |
0.98% |
|
Wagstaff |
100 |
0.98% |
|
Jones
S. |
102 |
0.98% |
|
ATTENDING
IN PERSON
BY
PROXY
BY
PROXY BUT WITHOUT VOTING RIGHT
TOTAL |
22
38
2
62 |
21.56%
41.18%
1.96%
64.70% |
The
President, Mrs Anne Head, the Vice-president, Mr. Sam Magee, and the
Secretary/Administrator, Mr Jon W. Olsen, were all present.
There
were thus 22 owners present and 37 proxies had been given, so that a total
of 59 owners were present or represented, making a total of 61.75 %, this
being sufficient to hold the general meeting in the First Call at 17:00.
2.
The President’s Report
The
President, Mrs Anne Head, opened the meeting by stating that, contrary to
reports circulated by her Vice President, she has never wished to stand
down due to her husband’s ill health. His recovery is now complete and
Mrs Head confirmed that she is able to offer her services as President for
the coming term.
She
continued by saying that if you are President or Vice President you should
be impartial on all matters and not denounce one owner for illegal
building and let off another owner who you are friends with.
Thanks
were given to the Board members and those who supported her during the
last year. It was a difficult year, with two Extraordinary General
Meetings, but improvements were made to the fresh water supply, swimming
pool, sewage disposal system and street lights.
The
maintenance company are now looking after all aspects of the complex,
including the swimming pool.
We
now have four new pumps for the waste disposal, one of which is a spare,
and are in the process of purchasing a winch to enable our maintenance
people to lift and clean the pumps on a regular basis. Owners are kindly
asked not to throw any objects, plastic bags etc in the toilets as they
damage the pumps and can obstruct the pipes.
Illegal
building works at houses 31, 82 and 97 have all been denounced to Yaiza
Council and these matters have been placed in the hands of our lawyer.
She
closed by advising that the new bus service is now in operation, and
thanked her Vice President and the Administrator for their assistance and
support whenever required.
Concerning
building matters, Sam Magee (58) asked the meeting to please refer to
Section 7 of the Horizontal Property Act.
3.
Examination and approval, if appropriate, of the annual accounts for the
year 2007/2008.
An
amount of €5.018 had been received from Club Lanzarote as a refund
against the recycling charge. Extra income of €8.160 had been received
from owners in respect of the pool repair costs.
Various
water losses during the year resulted in a cost of €7.857. Monthly water
controls are maintained but with no community plans, detecting the
location of the leaks has required substantial digging. Domestic waste
water expenses were high due to raw sewage running down in the streets on
several occasions resulting in the cost of numerous tankers to facilitate
disposal of the waste.
A
complete overhaul of the street lights has been undertaken over the year,
particularly on Phase 2. Administration and translation fees were higher
than budget because of the work involved in holding two EGMs.
The
previous Reserves of €14.523 have been spent, and the year ended with
deficit capital of €2.839. It was noted that Club Lanzarote has allowed
the community additional time to pay their water invoices.
The
“back water” amounts owing to Club Lanzarote originally totalling some
€96K have now been recovered with the exception of house no.82 which we
are still pursuing, together with their community debt. Some older amounts
involving Club Lanzarote have been referred back to them.
The
high cost of translations was queried. The Administrator replied that all
papers should be in Spanish, but because the majority of owners are
English, and with a small German contingent, all communications are made
in three languages as it is important that people should understand what
is going on.
The
Financial Statements for the year 2007/08 were approved unanimously by the
meeting.
4.
To update and agree on the list of debtors and to adopt resolutions for
taking legal steps for the recovery of outstanding amounts, giving the
necessary instructions and authorisations to the President. An updated
list of debtors will be presented at the meeting.
It
was agreed by the meeting that statutory interest of 20% per annum should
be charged to the following outstanding debts:
|
Unit
Number & Owner’s Name |
Outstanding
Fees |
Water |
Interest |
Total |
|
082
Baeza Benavides, Jesus |
1.439,00
€ |
393.94
€ |
238.86
€ |
2.071.80€ |
|
043
Casacoscan 2001, S.L. |
486,70
€ |
486.70
€ |
0
€ |
486.70€ |
|
090
Govani, Amyn |
234.00
€ |
39.78
€ |
11.70
€ |
285.48€ |
|
050
Jeynes, Don |
270.47
€ |
138.06
€ |
14.73
€ |
423.26€ |
|
020
Ruiz Roman |
522.88
€ |
465.66
€ |
39.24
€ |
1.027.78€
€ |
|
005
Sadilan, S.L. |
379.00
€ |
173.16
€ |
35.50
€ |
587.66€ |
|
079
Skipper, Miguel |
177,66
€ |
0.00
€ |
8.88
€ |
186.54€ |
It
was unanimously agreed to take legal action against these debtors.
Distribution of the minutes will serve as notice to these debtors and a
lawyer will be instructed to commence recovery proceedings immediately,
the costs of which will be borne by the community. If the debtor makes
opposition to the claim in court, the community has the right to register
the debt as an embargo on the property in question.
Owners
were advised that when Club Lanzarote undertakes the individual invoicing
for water consumption, they will be able to disconnect the water at
properties where payment has not been received.
The
meeting adjourned at 18:25, and reconvened again at 18:45.
The
President then read out a short statement from Clive & Olga Green (3)
in which they asked that the existing Board should continue to work
together for the good of the community.
5.
Proposals from the Board:
a.
To amend the second paragraph of section 24 of the bye laws to read
as follows; "The meeting elects a President, who represents the
community in legal matters and additionally in all the matters which
affect it. Additionally it elects a Secretary-Administrator, one or
more Vice-presidents and an Auditor. (Unanimous)
The
Administrator reported that proxies had been received from more than one
owner against this proposal. The decision has to be unanimous so this
proposal was not approved. Therefore a second Vice President/Treasurer
will be elected for 1 year.
6.
Elections
Candidates
for the position of President are Anne Head (65) standing for re-election,
Sam Magee (58) (currently Vice President) and José Hernandez (83) who
presented himself as a candidate at the meeting.
José
Hernandez commented that although he is pleased with the work done by the
previous Board over the last year, he hoped that the community would be
united going forward and the Board should, where possible, include owners
in decisions. He was of the opinion that if the Council approves building
works, then perhaps the works should not be rejected by the Board. He
asked for more control of expenses, more quotations for projects to be
undertaken, and perhaps install a letterbox for suggestions/comments from
owners.
19:10
Mr Herz (73) joined the meeting.
Results
of the voting for the position of President:
Anne
Head (65) 20 votes
José
Hernandez (83) 7 votes
Sam
Magee (58) 31 votes Total 58 votes, 1 abstain
19:20
José Hernandez (83) left the meeting.
Candidates
for the position of Vice President are Paul Bookless (15) and José
Hernandez (83).
Results
of the voting for the position of Vice President:
Paul
Bookless (15) 28 votes
José
Hernandez (83) 27 votes Total 55 votes, 4 abstains
Mr
Teifel (91) thanked the retiring Board for the work done over the last
year.
There
was only one candidate for the position of Vice President/Treasurer –
Roger Stansfield (76) – who was duly elected.
Jon
Olsen confirmed that he was happy to stand as Secretary/Administrator for
a further year and was duly elected.
Rudolf
Herz (73) volunteered to be Auditor for the year. The position is unpaid
and must be performed by a member of the community.
The
Administrator thanked the retiring President for her work during the last
year, and she wished the new Board well for the coming year.
5.
Proposals from the
Board:
b.
To erect a fence and install gates around the swimming pool so as to
increase security, in particular for children. The cost of this
depends on the quality and height of the fence and will be
approximately €12.000. (Simple majority)
Voting:
In favour : 24, 26, 64, 74
Abstain
: -
Against
: all others
c.
To tidy up, add some plants and install a watering system in the
unfinished area between phases 1 and 2 to the same standard as
around the swimming pool. Various quotes have been received, from
€4.500 to €7.500 (Simple majority)
Quotations
have been received from our current maintenance company, together with one
from Beautiful Gardens & Villas. In answer to a question, the
maintenance company are currently paid €2.190 per month to look after
the pool, communal gardens, roads, etc. If the proposal is approved, the
cost will be borne by a one-off payment from owners. After discussion,
voting was as follows:
19:50
Roach (71) left the meeting.
Against
: 9, 10, 12, 13, 14/21, 15, 16, 17, 48, 49, 74, 76,
77,
81, 83, 85, 86, 89, 92, 100, 102 = 22 votes
Abstain
: 18, 59, 88, 97
In
favour : 32 owners
The
proposal was not approved.
20:20
Armstrong (10) left the meeting.
For
the benefit of the meeting, the Administrator clarified the voting
procedures. When the meeting is held in the First Call (more than 50% of
the owners present or represented), resolutions need the simple majority
of all the members of the community to be adopted. If the meeting is held
in the Second Call (less than 50 % of the owners present or represented at
the meeting) resolutions require the simple majority of those present to
be adopted.
d.
To delete the current Internal Rules and to adopt the new set of
Rules presented by the Board. (Simple majority)
Comments
had been received from houses 15, 73 and 75. It was agreed that this
matter will be discussed by the new Board and revised Internal Rules will
be circulated prior to next year’s meeting.
e.
To install individual letterboxes as on the other phases of Faro
Park. Cost per property approximately €85.
The
letterboxes would be located at gate 1 and gate 3. Concern was expressed
over the boxes being filled with junk mail and post being wrongly
delivered to a box where an owner is absent for many months.
In
favour : 4, 45, 64, 70, 74, 93
Abstain
: 27, 59, 97
The
proposal was not approved.
6.
Proposals
from owners:
a.
From Mr. Sam Magee (58):
i.
That any Board members or officers of the community who have
access to personal details of their fellow owners use this
information with discretion while they are in office. On
retiring from office, use of this classified information is in
violation of the Data Protection Act. (Simple majority)
Against
: 13, 21, 26, 40, 48, 68, 74
Abstain
: -
The
proposal was therefore approved.
b.
From Mr. Tony Matthews (85): That I be reimbursed €581.04 in
telephone expenses for the three years that I was President. (Simple
majority)
The
meeting was informed that when Tony Matthews left office he had an amount
of €302 owing from a float of €500 given to him for the garden
project. He repaid €200, but claimed €102 for telephone expenses which
was reimbursed after approval by the Board. However, he then presented a
total claim of €581.04 with a list of his phone bills over the period,
but without the actual receipts.
After
discussion, it was agreed that Tony Matthews should have applied to the
Board at the end of his last year in office. No remuneration has been
received by Board members to date.
In
favour : 9, 13, 44, 51, 52, 53, 59, 64, 66, 68, 69, 75, 78, 85, 86, 89,
93
Abstain
: 4, 6, 12, 58, 61, 70, 76, 80, 81, 88, 91, 95, 96, 97, 102
The
proposal was not agreed.
a.
ii. That out of pocket expenses incurred by Board members be capped
at an agreed figure for each yearly term of appointment. (Simple
majority)
After
discussion it was proposed that a global figure should be paid between the
relevant Board members in recognition of the time and effort given to the
community.
Against
: 14/21, 26, 46, 65, 68, 74
Abstain
: 15, 58, 81, 83
In
favour : 3, 4, 6, 9, 12, 13, 16, 17, 18, 24, 33, 41, 44, 45, 48, 49, 51,
52,
53, 59, 61, 63, 64, 66, 69, 70, 73, 75, 76, 77, 78, 80, 85,
86, 88, 89, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 100, 102
The
proposal was approved.
It
was then agreed that the amount to be paid, with effect from 1st August
2008, will be €600 globally. The budget will not be changed; the cost
will be taken from “Various Expenses”.
Against
: 65
Abstain
: 14/21, 26, 68, 74, 83, 88
7.
Proposal for the yearly budget and stipulation of annual fees.
The
community fee per villa is budgeted to remain unchanged at €78 per
month.
Val
Morgan (16) enquired whether the administration fee will be reduced when
Club Lanzarote take over responsibility for water meter readings and
subsequent invoicing. The Administrator confirmed that his fee would then
reduce. However, Club Lanzarote will start with communities where they
have debtor problems and therefore Faro Park Phases 1&2 will be one of
the last communities to convert over.
The
Budget for 2008/09 was unanimously approved.
8.
Any other business
Alan
Crabtree (77) questioned why the Summons for the meeting was received by
e-mail and then by registered post. The Administrator replied that he has
to certify that the Summons has been received. If an owner declares at the
start of the meeting that he has not received the Summons, the meeting can
be invalidated.
21:30
Jackie James (52) left the meeting.
Sam
Magee (58) thanked Anne Head for her report and also extended thanks to
Christine and Pino in the office.
The
meeting closed at 21:35.
Playa
Blanca, 3rd October 2008
Approved
by
| Jon
W. Olsen |
Anne
Head |
| Secretary/
Administrator |
President |
|